Ninja vs. Vitamix Debate: Which Blender is the Best Value and the Best Performer?
When shopping for a blender, there is no doubt that the process can quickly go from exciting to overwhelming because of all of the different sources of information out there online.
It’s not just selecting which product you’re buying; it’s the function you’ll primarily use your blender for, price point, brand, size, and maintenance.
Do you want to buy a blender to make smoothies, soups, and sauces? Or are you into holistic eating and aspire to craft your own butter, flours, and herbal mixes? This will determine the type of blades you’ll want and versatility of speeds.
Quick Vitamix vs. Ninja Comparison
- Up to 2HP Motor
- 37,000 max RPMs
- Four-prong blade designed for crushing ice and liquefying ingredients
- Come included with multiple containers
- Refined controls giving you tons of options
- 1000-1500 Watts
- 24,000 max RPMs
- Vertical six-blade tower made for easy cleaning.
- Come included with multiple containers
- 3 speed options, simplifying your experience
Another aspect of blender buying to keep in mind is size. Are you going to be making smoothies for the masses, or just 1-2 servings at a time? You also want to think about your counter space and whether you’ll want a small enough blender to tuck away, or if you have a permanent space for it to live.
Which Blender Is Better?
|Blender/Model||HP / Watts||Blades||Container Size||Unique Feature||Price Guide|
|Vitamix 5200||2 HP||4 laser cut, stainless steel blades||64 oz.||Can bring cold ingredients to hot in minutes.||High|
|Ninja Professional Blender NJ600||1000 Watts||Ninja 6-Blade Technology||72 oz.||Ultimate ice crushing action.||Moderate|
There are a lot of different models on the market, each with a variety of features and price points. We took a look at two of the popular blender lines on the market – the Ninja and the Vitamix.
The Ninja and Vitamix are two blenders that are commonly cherished by those wanting powerful blenders and that desire a solid size blender, but nothing too over-the-top. They both have blades that liquidize ice in just seconds. Maintenance is certainly easy with both of these machines.
Which Blender Blends the Best?
Both the Ninja and Vitamix lines are destructive threats to solids like ice, fruit, vegetables, and seeds. They can both easily perform basic blender operations such as crushing ice, making drinks and blending both fruits and vegetables. For the cook who dabbles in more advanced techniques of preparing, cooking, and serving, however, there are some differences when comparing the Ninja blender vs Vitamix.
The Vitamix operates on 1380 watts. The Ninja line varies between 1000 and 1500 watts, depending on the specific model. For our tests, we used the best-selling Ninja Professional NJ600 (1000 watts) and the Ninja Ultimate (1500 watts).
Regarding raw power, we have to give the advantage to the Vitamix. Despite a more powerful engine, the Ninja blenders struggle a bit with whole frozen fruit and foods like peanut butter. The Ninja line still works great on softer, more traditional items.
The Vitamix has a wide range of speed settings. You can adjust the speed anywhere between 500 and 37,000 RPMs. At the higher speeds, the blender is a bit on the loud side. Still, we think that’s a reasonable trade-off considering this is of the fastest blenders available.
The Ninja models have three set speeds. Speed One is suitable for dough. Speed Two is used for the majority of blending. Speed Three works well for ice crushing and frozen drinks. At Speed Three, the blender has a speed of 24,000 RPMs.
Both blenders can make dough. However, to make dough with the Ninja line you’ll need to purchase the Dough Blade and Dough Paddle attachments. The Vitamix requires no additional accessories for dough.
The Vitamix has four stainless steel blades. Two are cutting blades and the other two are blunt hammer mill blades. Vitamix claims their blades will keep their edge even after thousands of blends. While we couldn’t test the Vitamix that extensively, internet reviews generally back this claim up.
The Ninja line uses a vertical six-blade tower. The tower is easily removable, giving the Ninja line a slight edge (pun definitely intended) in “cleanability.” Be careful, however. The blades are extremely sharp and can definitely cut your hands if you’re not careful.
What Types of Containers are Available?
There are several container size options for each line of blenders. Each is made from BPA-Free plastic. This is important because BPA’s (bisphenol A), a common chemical that has been used to make plastics for 40 years, can be severely detrimental to your health.
Though the Food and Drug Administration used to believe BPAs were acceptable to use in manufacturing, the standards were altered in 2010. There are potential effects on the brain, behavior, and many other aspects of your well-being. It is critical to buy a blender that does not have BPA in its products (1). When comparing the Ninja vs. Vitamix, you want to select the blender with the types of containers you’ll use.
The container options for the Vitamix include:
- 64 ounce container (both standard and low profile)
- 48 ounce container
- 32 ounce container
- 32 ounce dry grains container
Container options for the Ninja line include:
- 72 ounce pitches
- 40 ounce bowl
- Single serving cups
Which Blender is Easier to Use?
The Vitamix has more refined controls than the Ninja line. By refined, we mean simple, but that doesn’t take away from the strength of the blender. The Vitamix has a Hi/Low switch. Each Vitamix blender includes a tamper, useful for blending solid foods and frozen entrees.
The Ninja line has three set speeds and as well as a pulse button for you to have more control over how blended something is getting. An instance when you’d want to pulse versus blend is when creating a particular sauce that you don’t necessarily want to puree. Also, protein powder can change the texture of a smoothie if blended too quickly in with other smoothie ingredients.
While these speeds were fine, the presence of the blade tower made it difficult to sample whatever is being blended. If you would like a taste of your delicious creation, be careful and use a spoon rather than a finger. However, this inconvenience is very quickly overshadowed by all of the great positives to the Ninja. The Lock-In Lever – a suction cup feature on the base of the device -- has been particularly useful in preventing movement while blending thick material such as dough.
Ninja vs. Vitamix: Which is Easier to Keep Clean?
We found both blenders were pretty easy to keep clean. The Vitamix is a bit different from other blenders in that the bottom blade is not easily removed. The best way to clean the Vitamix is to pour warm water and detergent into the blend, then blend for about 10 seconds. You also want to be sure to dry thoroughly, or else the blender can develop a musty smell. If this is the case, be sure to stick it in the dishwasher without the blades.
The Ninja can be cleaned in the same manner. Also, all of the blades in the blender are removable, which makes cleaning a snap. Just be careful of the sharp blades and scrub them with a brush with your hands and fingers kept at a distance.
Our Final Conclusion
Both the Ninja and the Vitamix are powerful blenders and both fantastic investments. The payoff to your convenience, health, environmental-friendliness, and wallet is incredibly worth it. Blenders in the Vitamix line run from about $300 to $700. The products in the Ninja line are generally less expensive, starting around $130.
There are many factors to consider when comparing the Ninja vs. Vitamix blenders. The Vitamix is a bit more powerful, and probably the best choice if you regularly blend thick or frozen foods. On the other hand, the Ninja line is easier to clean. Which blender will work best for you depends on your specific needs, but both lines have a lot to offer. Happy blending!